Interactive webcast player
Governance & Audit Committee
Thursday, 19th November 2026 at 10:00am
Speaking:
Start of webcast
Share this agenda point
1 Chair's Update
Share this agenda point
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
2 Apologies for Absence
Share this agenda point
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
3 Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary Interests
Share this agenda point
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
4 Exempt Information - Possible Exclusion of the Press and Public
Share this agenda point
-
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer
-
Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
5 Minutes of the Meeting held 8 October 2026
Share this agenda point
-
Rob Winter (Independent Member)
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
6 Risk Management
Share this agenda point
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer
-
Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Cllr Robin Cumming CA Member
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer
-
Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer
-
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer
-
Cllr Robin Cumming CA Member
-
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer
-
Cllr Robin Cumming CA Member
-
Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer
-
Cllr Robin Cumming CA Member
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Cllr Robin Cumming CA Member
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Cllr Robin Cumming CA Member
-
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer
-
Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer
-
Rob Winter (Independent Member)
-
Cllr David Dews
-
Kate Taylor, Director West Yorkshire Combined Authority
-
Cllr David Dews
-
Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer
-
Cllr David Dews
-
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer
-
Kate Taylor, Director West Yorkshire Combined Authority
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer
-
Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer
-
Cllr John Taylor CA Member
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Cllr John Taylor CA Member
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Cllr John Taylor CA Member
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer
-
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer
-
Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer
-
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer
-
Cllr John Taylor CA Member
-
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer
-
Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Rob Winter (Independent Member)
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Rob Winter (Independent Member)
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Rob Winter (Independent Member)
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer
-
Cllr Robin Cumming CA Member
-
Bronwyn Baker, Officer (West Yorkshire Combined Authority)
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Cllr Alex Greenwood CA Member
-
Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer
-
Cllr Alex Greenwood CA Member
-
Kate Taylor, Director West Yorkshire Combined Authority
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Rob Winter (Independent Member)
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Rob Winter (Independent Member)
-
Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer
-
Rob Winter (Independent Member)
-
Kate Taylor, Director West Yorkshire Combined Authority
-
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer
-
Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer
-
Rob Winter (Independent Member)
-
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer
-
Cllr David Dews
-
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer
-
Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Cllr David Jenkins CA Member
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Cllr David Jenkins CA Member
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Cllr David Jenkins CA Member
-
Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Cllr David Jenkins CA Member
6 Risk Management
Share this agenda point
-
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer
-
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer
-
Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer
7 External Audit Update
Share this agenda point
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Alastair Newall (Auditor) Mazars
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Rob Winter (Independent Member)
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Alastair Newall (Auditor) Mazars
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Rob Winter (Independent Member)
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Kate Taylor, Director West Yorkshire Combined Authority
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Rob Winter (Independent Member)
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Kate Taylor, Director West Yorkshire Combined Authority
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Kate Taylor, Director West Yorkshire Combined Authority
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Rob Winter (Independent Member)
-
Rob Winter (Independent Member)
-
Kate Taylor, Director West Yorkshire Combined Authority
-
Rob Winter (Independent Member)
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Cllr Alex Greenwood CA Member
-
Kate Taylor, Director West Yorkshire Combined Authority
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Cllr Cllr Simon Brophy Kirklees Council
-
Cllr Robin Cumming CA Member
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Cllr Robin Cumming CA Member
-
Kate Taylor, Director West Yorkshire Combined Authority
-
Kate Taylor, Director West Yorkshire Combined Authority
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
-
Rob Winter (Independent Member)
-
Kate Taylor, Director West Yorkshire Combined Authority
-
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member)
8 Q2 Treasury Management Update
10 Date of Next Meeting
Share this agenda point
-
Webcast Finished
Disclaimer: This transcript was automatically generated, so it may contain errors. Please view the webcast to confirm whether the content is accurate.
1 Chair's Update
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:00:08
Good morning everybody and welcome to governance and audit committee meeting 19th of November.Before we begin I'd like to remind everyone to switch on the microphone before speaking
and turn it off again when they've finished. We've received some feedback from members
of the public watching the live stream that at times it's been difficult to follow the
discussion when microphones haven't been used consistently. So if you could just bear
that in mind please as we move forward. I think I should just say before we start that
I think this set of papers shows changes in content and presentation and that's been
introduced as a result of our feedback. So I'd just like to thank the officers for
and taking our views into account and presenting these changes. I think we've got some papers
which have got a lot more clarity and a lot easier to read than we've had before, so thank
2 Apologies for Absence
you for that. Okay, Agenda Item 2, apologies for absence.
We have apologies from David Merritt and Councillor Hickson.
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:01:15
Thank you.3 Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary Interests
Gender item 3, declarations of disposable Q &A interests.
Can any members highlight any declarations of interest, please?
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:01:31
No, I think that's nothing to declare there.4 Exempt Information - Possible Exclusion of the Press and Public
Thank you.
Gender item 4, that's exempt information.
We have one item on that for today.
that's item 6 risk management appendix 2 which is a corporate ROAP which is exempt. The lead
director on that is Nicky and it's recommended that in accordance with paragraph 3 part 1
schedule 12A to the local government act 1972 the public be excluded from the meeting during
consideration of item 6 risk management appendix 2 on the grounds that it's likely to view
in view of the nature of the business to be transacted or the nature of proceedings, that
if members of the press and public were present, there'd be disclosure to them of exempt information
and for the reasons set out in the report that in all circumstances of the case, the
public interest in maintaining the exemption outweighs the public interest in disclosing
the information.
I invite Statutory Monitoring Officer Nicky to provide further clarification here on the
scope and consideration undertaken in this regard.
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer - 0:02:48
Thank you, Chair. Just to provide some clarification on this, I know that members are very keenNikki Deol Chief Legal Officer - 0:02:50
for transparency in the reports, particularly in relation to corporate risks that are facedby the organisation. We've very carefully considered the comments that members took,
provided in relation to risk generally and being more transparent in our reporting to
you as a committee.
However, given that these relate to cybersecurity
prevention and also cyber incident and loss of
business continuity, and in light of what happened last
week with the worldwide outage for Microsoft, it's
important that we maintain that confidentiality going
forward.
You've obviously got information before you're
in an exempt paper, so you have seen the detail of
that, but in my view, applying the legal tests,
it's not appropriate to expose the authority, its business affairs and its security to have
those out in the public domain and therefore I've taken that balancing exercise and considered
that they should remain exempt and I'd invite members to vote on that proposal that they
are retained as exempt going forward.
Thank you, so could we have a vote on that proposal please, all in favour?
5 Minutes of the Meeting held 8 October 2026
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:03:59
Thank you. Okay, agenda item five is minutes of the meetingheld on the 8th of October, 2026, and the recommendation is for members of the committee
to review and agree. Has anybody got any comments on the minutes,
please? Rob?
Rob Winter (Independent Member) - 0:04:25
I wasn't at the last meeting but it's a matter of principle of governance and audit committeeminutes being perhaps providing a little bit more context.
So obviously it's not required or appropriate for them to be a verbatim account that he
said that and she said the other.
But I think an example, you know, it's a simple example, but around the data protection officer
report, questions were also raised regarding compliance with mandated information governance
training.
But in the minutes, there's no context as to whether that was good, bad, indifferent,
and as a public record, I just think there's perhaps a little bit more context that could
be added.
the details of the report, because clearly that's inappropriate because that report exists,
but just to reflect a little bit more of the discursive nature and context of each item.
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:05:26
// Thanks, Rob. I can ask officers to reflect on that. Thank you. Any other comments onpoints of accuracy or anything? No. Councillor Broughy, did you have something?
or no no council coming to you okay yeah no that's lovely thank you so could we
take a vote please to approve the minutes one in favour yeah thank you
6 Risk Management
okay so gender item six is risk management and the recommendation for
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:06:07
this paper is that the committee notes the progress made in implementing therisk management system the development plan and embedding risk management
arrangements across the authority and also that we note the status of the current corporate
risks as set out in appendix 1 and information contained within the corporate risk register
detailed in appendix 2.
So Nicky are you presenting this paper please?
I am.
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer - 0:06:37
I'm presenting this paper on behalf of the risk manager who is virtually absent today.Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer - 0:06:39
I'm happy to take questions and if I'm not able to answer those questions I will certainlytake those away and respond by email.
As you can see members the report sets out the current activity that's being undertaken
in relation to the risk management strategy that the authority has adopted and the assurance
that we consider is being undertaken on the effectiveness of the current risk management
arrangements but also those particular corporate risks that are in your pack.
You will recall from our previous discussions when the management strategy was presented
to you, we are moving away from simply recording it so that you can see it but we are moving
into a management activity where we have got a bit of a routine compliance and critical
view on how risk is being managed generally within the organisation.
And that is now embedded, we consider, within the decision reporting, the initiation documents
that we have when projects are launched, how we do workforce planning, and also performance
reporting as well.
Internal audit clarifies where there are weaknesses as a line of defence.
We make sure that we reflect that within the report that you see before you today.
What I would say is that training is continuing for the organisation given the there are a number of changing
platforms and including workforce changes as well
So we're continuing that training to make sure that everyone's aware of what the strategy requires of them
So turning to the corporate board
To the corporate risks that have in your pack
What you'll see is that following some feedback in relation to the the risks themselves
themselves, there is an increase in the number of risks that have been identified as very
high. Now, that shouldn't automatically be interpreted as us not being resilient or safe,
but rather a recognition of us identifying and articulating that risk correctly, strategically.
So we as a risk management team consider that the organisation is identifying those risks
correctly and not being afraid to identify them as very high, because that's not the
of risk management, but making sure that effective controls are being deployed at the right time.
You've also will notice from your papers that we've reshaped some of the risks, particularly
those where comments were received around protective security, which are CR14 and CO18.
We consider that they can be de -escalated and put down to a level that's managed through
directorates rather than coming to you as a governance and audit committee and moving
them from a corporate risk register.
A lot of you in your own councils will have similar risks but they are managed as a BAU
activity at a directorate level rather than being reported upwards.
So you'll see that for protective security.
In addition we've reshaped the mass transit programme and you'll see that it reappears
We have far more detail now at CR28, and that relates specifically to the strategic outline
business case which will be presented to the combined authority for approval next month,
and that will be subject to approval and submission to the DFT.
We have also changed some risk profiling around policy and stakeholder alignment to make sure
that that's not solely linked to programmes,
but a recognition that that can go cross -cutting
across a number of programmes
that the authorities are undertaking.
And equally, we've done that for CRR 31,
which relates to delivery cost and market
fatality and global economic changes.
Again, in recognition that that doesn't just respond
to mass transit, but a number of major profile
and programmes that we're undertaking,
because cost escalation can face us in a whole suite of programmes that we have.
So those are set out for you. The report sets it out and then your Appendix 6 has the risks
on the page. I'm happy to take questions on those if members would like to. Equally, if
you would like to talk about the exempt items, we'll have to go into a closed session. That's
all I've got to say at this moment in time, Chair. Thank you.
Thank you.
If we can take questions on everything except the exempt items, please.
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:11:08
Anyone have any queries?Yes, Councillor CUNNINGHAM.
I apologise.
Cllr Robin Cumming CA Member - 0:11:14
I have not been that well to look at these in any great detail before I came.I have already mentioned that.
But in general terms, I'm looking at these risks and they are all very high.
But the target likelihood to get them, most of them are unlikely.
you know so are they not actually working on it?
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:11:33
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer - 0:11:39
Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer - 0:11:42
I totally take that on board because it's that appetite the risk appetite that we've got as well and are we assessing it too high against thelikelihood. Some of those risks the likelihood of it happening might be low
but that doesn't mean that you descale it you take it into account and you make
sure that the controls that you've got in place are adequate. What we don't know
is some of those are outside of our control so that might lead the risk
owner and the sponsor to set the likelihood a bit lower but we can
certainly review that in line with what risk owners assessment is.
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer - 0:12:14
Cllr Robin Cumming CA Member - 0:12:15
The question is you have a target yeah so you really want to get to that target soreally having them you know we're very high the targets medium yeah target
likelihood unlikely. So it just means like what are you actually working on to get to
that target. There's no explanation why you're not saying it's unlikely not to meet it.
So I'd have to go to the specific risks so that we can examine those. Which ones have
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer - 0:12:42
you got in mind, Councillor?I mean, take any of them, you know.
Cllr Robin Cumming CA Member - 0:12:45
Vitality is very high current, and targets, well,I don't see that one.
Very high.
Yeah, that's a difficult one.
All the workers there is very high, and the targets medium.
When you've got possible, that's probably the best way to go.
Condition status, very high, unlikely,
and you're trying to get to low.
So, you know, is it because you've got too low?
Well, I think there's a lot of activity that's been undertaken on the assets. What we'd want
Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer - 0:13:16
to do is we've acquired a number of assets and we're continuing to do that through busfranchising.
I won't try to get at it as a summary table. It looks bad reading.
Yes, okay.
Cllr Robin Cumming CA Member - 0:13:27
As a summary table, yeah, that's, you know, just at a summary level.Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:13:32
I think this also aligns with discussions as committees have before about bringing peoplein to talk to us about the risks and we have done that and so I think if there
are risks there that we're concerned about I think we should be asking to
speak to the officers for a more detailed update in terms of exactly what
you say what what they're doing what the plan of action is so we can bring them
to the next meeting and so yeah
Cllr Robin Cumming CA Member - 0:14:01
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:14:03
Cllr Robin Cumming CA Member - 0:14:05
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer - 0:14:13
And I appreciate that and I think what we should do for you as a governance and auditNikki Deol Chief Legal Officer - 0:14:19
committee is that we rotate a number of owners and bring them to you so they can specifyspecifically why it's been assessed at that stage. We can implement that for the next
committee so we pick out three or four of the risks and the owners can give you, and
the sponsors can give you that clarification as to why it's been assessed in that way rather
the new looking at it blankly in a report you need context this it goes
back to the point that the independent member raised about making sure that
you've got the context fully and we'll we'll definitely implement that for you
and then Councillor Gee's and then Councillor Turner.
Rob Winter (Independent Member) - 0:14:52
Cllr David Dews - 0:15:01
There's a lot of detail identifying all the risks.I'm just wondering about the follow -up to this
and whether things are actually done,
because I noticed on one of them in the small print,
This is risk 6, operator bus services.
There's one little thing here that says,
new and emerging issues around school transport income,
resulting in the need to undertake consultation ahead of 26, 27.
So that's something that should have happened presumably before April.
And it's still there.
Is there follow up on some of these risks?
So in relation to that one, yes there is.
Kate Taylor, Director West Yorkshire Combined Authority - 0:15:53
So we undertook phase one of a school bus consultationtowards the kind of the back end of last year
and enacted some of those.
The team have gone to phase two.
So that was a policy decision made by the CA board,
probably going back to 25, 26.
Phase two, I think at the moment is scheduled
to come to the Weaver board in the new year for discussion. There has been
discussion with districts about that before that which has slightly delayed
the timescale of that now coming through to Weaver board for that time.
Cllr David Dews - 0:16:28
Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer - 0:16:30
So Councillor just in terms of follow -up because that's the key point of yourquestion is that you specify what's happening in terms of activity but you
don't know when it's discharged. What we'll be doing as Kate has said when that
goes to Weave a Network board, the owner will update this and say that was the decision
made and this now moves to implementation.
Cllr David Dews - 0:16:47
It was just that it was down under future risk.That relates to the decision that's yet to be made, so it is a future risk.
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer - 0:16:59
I think we would say that decision has to be made by a board of this authority, thatKate Taylor, Director West Yorkshire Combined Authority - 0:17:02
is not a decision that sits with officers to make alone because it is a policy decision.Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:17:06
So I think there's something there just about having complete clarity.A bit more detail, I think.
Not masses, but just a bit so we get that context again.
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer - 0:17:15
Yeah, no, absolutely.Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer - 0:17:17
We'll take that on board, Councillor Gies, and we'll make sure that it's clear as towhat the target date is of that or anticipated decision at which point it can be discharged.
Thanks, Nikki.
Councillor Taylor.
Yeah.
Just a couple of things.
Cllr John Taylor CA Member - 0:17:32
First, going back to the conversation we were having a little earlier, certainly my experiencein corporate governance and audit in Kirklees, our role isn't to manage risks.
Our role is to seek assurance that risks are being properly managed.
So for me, I'm not sure I want all of the risk managers to be coming here and explaining
everything, but what we have done in the past in Kirklees is we've picked at random one
or two corporate risks, and we've stepped through the process to understand how it's
got to the risk level that it's got and the way it's managed and whether we feel that
just to give us the reassurance, because that's our job, to get that reassurance that risks
are being managed, because that's what we need assurance on, and we don't need to try
and manage the risks. That's not our job. That's other people's roles, isn't it? So
I just think that might be a suggestion, you know, rather than having everybody coming
all of the time and telling us everything, because that's not our job.
Our job is to find that, to get that reassurance, and one way we can get that reassurance, really,
is by stepping through a process and understanding the risk process to give us reassurance that
the risk process is embedded and is working properly, and therefore the information we're
we can rely on the information that's presented to us, because we understand how that ended
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:18:58
Cllr John Taylor CA Member - 0:18:59
up at that position really. So that's one point. But my other point, and I get a bitgrumpy about this, you'll get used to me getting a bit grumpy occasionally. When I read things
that are out of date, it says to me this isn't being well managed. So if I just take, for
I have now got to find this one.
If you look at it, is that the one more?
Is the capability and capacity constraints on capital delivery, is it that one?
Hold on, we're looking at 13 isn't it?
So when I look at future risk controls required mitigation plan, so we've got some future
risk controls required but the date they're going to be delivered is Q2 this year, which
means they should have been delivered by now. So when I see things like that, that says
to me that risk isn't being managed. And there are a number of those dotted throughout this.
And I know I missed the last meeting because it was unwell, but I raised a similar issue
at the first meeting with risks, and it doesn't seem like anything has been done about it.
Somebody has a responsibility and a duty to look at these before they're presented to
this board and make sure they're accurate. And that clearly isn't happening. And that
undermines completely any reassurance I get about risks, because it says it's not being
managed. Because if it was being managed, that risk owner would be making sure that
the information that's presented to us is accurate. And it's clearly not accurate.
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:20:52
Cllr John Taylor CA Member - 0:20:55
Thank you, Councillor. So I think there's a fair amount of work toDebbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:20:58
do on that, still. Thanks, Councillor Taylor. Did you want toNikki Deol Chief Legal Officer - 0:21:00
come back on that, Nicky? No, I think that's a fair point. It's aboutMeg Williams Committee Services Officer - 0:21:06
consistency and making sure that they're not just providing matters that are out of date,Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer - 0:21:09
making sure that they're reading through the whole risk register and clarifying whetherthose dates are achievable or not. So we can certainly take that back to the risk owners
and the sponsors. We do sort of send reminders through the risk management team, but as you
say, this is a matter for the risk owner and the risk sponsors to make sure that they're
clarifying why those dates haven't been met or correcting the dates so that you're assured
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer - 0:21:33
that it is being done.Cllr John Taylor CA Member - 0:21:37
I think it's more than that, it's do they respect this committee? Because if they'resending information that's out of date or they're not checking that before it's submitted,
that suggests they have no respect for us as a committee and that's a red flag to me
and I think that's the message that needs to be taken back.
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer - 0:21:53
Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer - 0:21:57
I will certainly convey that message but I can certainly say that the officers do respectyou as a committee. It's certainly not done in that intended way but I'll clarify why
those dates and the accuracy is flawed.
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:22:12
Thank you and I do fully take on board and agree with your point Councillor Taylor. It'sa process we should be and this is probably an indication that that process isn't working
quite as well. I think the committee has spoken about that before hasn't it said we need to
understand that the process is working. The evidence for it working is probably seeing
a change in the risks. So I think we can't take that out completely, but we definitely
need to focus on the process. So we'll make sure that happens in terms of people coming
to this committee to talk to us. I think we've got Rob and then Councillor
of the meetings.
Rob Winter (Independent Member) - 0:22:45
I think we have got to the point now where show us, we have been told but show us andNick has already mentioned about having risk owners come to the meetings and I would take
Councillor Taylor's point about, you know, staying in our lane as an audit committee.
However, I think there is something really powerful of the risk owner explaining the
influence that the risk management process is having on how they are dealing with that
particular issue and exemplifying the arrangements and the processes through I don't think we
need a big report, it's literally the risk owner coming and just talking through their
particular risk and saying why is it a risk, some sort of rationale for the scoring because
we place I think potentially a distracting attention to the scores and actually I'd like
to see when somebody comes in front of the audit committee saying right, risk owner,
What's your level of assurance that this risk is being managed effectively?
And back to the point made earlier about some of the very likely and, you know, all the
scores.
If some of the refinement to the scores have recognised that the previous ones weren't
as accurate as they could be, how do we know the new ones are accurate?
So I think there's something about stripping back from this fixation we've all got with
heat maps and scores and saying, right, what arrangements have we got?
got in place that enables us to deal with this thing,
and to what extent is the risk owner assured
that all those things are in place
and therefore having an effect.
And I think that's a far more powerful way
of demonstrating good risk and governance management
than necessarily having sort of scores on the doors.
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:24:54
Rob Winter (Independent Member) - 0:24:56
But I think there's something about in the report,and I'm gonna go through more, but even paragraph 3 .2,
The second sentence, whilst further development remains necessary, management considers that
measurable progress has been made, et cetera.
How have they come to that conclusion?
What can we see that demonstrates that management have come to that conclusion?
And then just the last point I'll make is as an example in paragraph 3 .9, increasing
integration of risk management into these core business processes provides assurance,
but assurance to who?
Is that assurance to management? Because it isn't assurance to us yet. So I think it's
just in certain areas bringing it a little bit more to life of show us rather than just
tell us.
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:25:46
Thanks Rob, I think that's helpful and I think if we can come back to that in the workshopafterwards because we can try and shape that up a little bit more so we've got something
to work with.
Rob Winter (Independent Member) - 0:25:58
just to hog the floor for just another 30 seconds, I've noticed within the risks ona page some of the existing controls are written in a future tense, which infers that they're
not existing controls. If there's a plan to do something or it's being reviewed or it's
going to be introduced, infers that it's not existing. So I think there's just some of
the wording. The detail is probably in the system that how it's been captured in the
risks on a page I think is a bit confusing and not really helpful for an assurance perspective.
It's given us information but we need to form a view as to how assured we are, even beyond
being reassured we need to form our own view of how assured we are.
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:26:43
So when we do the workshop Rob I suggest that we start with that question and work backwardsfrom that and that might help us. I think we've got a really good starting point here
and I think one of the advantages of the work done to date is that we can see that sort
of gap now, whereas before it maybe wasn't as evident, so I think that's good. It's not
wasted work at all.
No, no, and I'm very grateful for all of the feedback that you as members are giving, because
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer - 0:27:09
accuracy is key for you discharging your duties as well as the committee.Thank you.
Councillor Comane.
Cllr Robin Cumming CA Member - 0:27:19
Two points, one with Councillor Taylor's point. When you go through and say, oh this is outof day because it's passed.
And this was brought up in the very first meeting
because I brought it up.
When you change a date that you've missed,
we want a reason why it was missed
and what you're going to do.
So don't just say, we've missed quarter two,
let's change it to quarter three.
We need to understand why it was missed.
And that's my first point.
The second point is the last meeting you two weren't about.
But we did talk about this, bringing people forward,
because it was a lot of the risk.
we did feel that they were ignoring us.
As an audit committee we were saying why are you doing this?
And they were just ignoring us.
And part of the minutes was we were going to actually
ask them to come in.
Those that were failing or those that yourself felt
that you were being ignored.
And I thought we were actually bringing that in.
Sorry, just to clarify, I think that was specifically
Bronwyn Baker, Officer (West Yorkshire Combined Authority) - 0:28:15
in relation to the audit recommendations and the risksthat that was identified.
I think the extension of that to this is entirely appropriate
and proper, so it is definitely something we need to consider.
And definitely want to pick up in the workshop so that we all
agree what that approach looks like, because some of the
commentary we've had so far is in order for it to be
meaningful, it has to be timely, so we need to forward plan it
effectively so that people are actually here in the current
meeting, not necessarily being called forward to future
meetings when that issue may actually have moved on by that
point. So I think we do need to really nail that down and get a process that we're all
content with. Thank you, Chet.
Thank you.
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:28:58
Cllr Alex Greenwood CA Member - 0:29:01
Yes, I'd also like to just comment that I too would like to see some palpable evidencethat the risk work is actually changing behaviour and influencing decisions on an operational
basis. I have three specific questions about risk on a page. Two quick, one slightly longer.
So, 002, I wondered, does the risk approach cover both accidental and intentional incidents?
It should, Councillor. Right. 005, are we at a point where staff retention
and loss of institutional memory are a serious delivery risk, and if so, what are we doing
to protect key knowledge.
Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer - 0:29:47
and they are, there are things that are being bought, they are assembling the capabilityand capacity going forward for certain key points.
Cllr Alex Greenwood CA Member - 0:30:21
So this will address any issue with key person dependency, that kind of thing?Yes it will.
My last one was 004 which is what actually are the practical consequences if we do not
deliver the agreed outcomes of the integrated settlement.
So the way in which the integrated settlement was always constructed ultimately was that
Kate Taylor, Director West Yorkshire Combined Authority - 0:30:53
there is, and this is kind of set out and publicly available, is what they call an interventionmatrix effectively. So if you are not, and it's not just actually the outcomes that would
be on there. There are also other warning signs, for example, as CLG would call it,
like for example, a qualified audit opinion, that would – so it goes down that matrix
and then if you start to hit into those tiers, effectively CLG can – so the ministry for
communities and local government that is kind of I guess our home department could put interventions
in in that place, so that could be that they ask for further or more regular monitoring,
for example, of spend in terms of that. So that's at the very worst end of it. In terms
of actually delivering programmes, what they have effectively said in there is we would
never be at risk of clawback of cash that we had spent where that had been spent in
genuine good faith of delivering those outcomes. If there are then systemic reasons why those
outcomes might not have been delivered, that would be considered by CLG and it might affect
future funding, for example. So if you are not delivering enough of your skills targets,
for example, that might suggest that you don't need as much money, for example, in the future
in that area, and they would factor that into their next spending review and of course conversation
about outcomes within there. So we would never have to give back a hundred million pound,
for example, that we had already spent and therefore be in a very difficult financial
situation.
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:32:35
Rob.Thanks, Chair.
Rob Winter (Independent Member) - 0:32:41
Just picking up on Councillor Greenwood's comment about risk 005, the explanation thatI couldn't recognise in the actual risk on a page documentation.
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:32:56
Sorry, Rob, where are you looking?Rob Winter (Independent Member) - 0:33:03
On the risks CRR005 that Councillor Greenwood referred to and the response that Nicky gaveto it which sounded a perfectly good explanation for action being taken, I couldn't recognise
actually being recorded on the risk on the page. Can I draw your attention to business
Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer - 0:33:21
planning and budgeting to consider how effective use of resources is embeddedwithin that. I suppose it's again that element of detail that your explanation
Rob Winter (Independent Member) - 0:33:33
was more helpful than that very sort of truncated comment. Yeah so we we arelooking at that risk so that risk actually used to originally sit with the
Chief Operating Officer post, so it actually was more expansive about the capability and
Kate Taylor, Director West Yorkshire Combined Authority - 0:33:48
capacity when that person left. I inherited it in terms of their, which isn't necessarilymy remit in there, so we are just looking at those risks at the moment to make sure
that we have got the requisite financial risks, which are ultimately two in terms of their,
which is in -year fiscal shock and long -term financial sustainability. And as part of that,
we will also make sure that we are covering that capacity and capability. We can make
sure that if in doing that we've kind of lost this one and we need to bring this one in,
but we'll need to consider whether we think that is an actual risk at this point in time.
So across the programmes as well specifically, and that's more on the directorate registers
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer - 0:34:36
Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer - 0:34:38
to sort of cover the point that Councillor Greenwood, we deal with that resourcing andexpertise matter at a directorate level but this is also as Kate says part of that wider
financial modelling as well and something that's been inherited from a legacy risk register.
Rob Winter (Independent Member) - 0:34:57
One thing I've seen in a number of council risk registers is something that's phrasedaround organisational resilience that just picks up the general capacity and expertise
which might include succession planning for key critical posts, the extent to which there's
good supervision and management, leadership, development, all the things that enable and
facilitate an organisation operating really resiliently. Forget the money, forget the
pressures, but just that focus on the capacity and capability of the workforce is perhaps
a way to think about that that can be a bit more of a corporate perspective, acknowledging
that within individual directorates there might be nuances of this that need to be reflected
at that level. Noted. We can take that back to our internal
boards and flag that as maybe something that needs to be more of an overarching rather
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer - 0:35:59
than simply being reported at directorate level so that we take a step back. I can saythat there is being work undertaken in relation to organisational design with that in mind.
Thank you. Councillor Dews.
Cllr David Dews - 0:36:12
Thank you. Risk 017, the incident management. I'm sure it's something that's being lookedat but with the Microsoft issue last week, did the risk control measures that we've got
here, did they actually work and are these being reviewed now?
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer - 0:36:36
Obviously there is an overlap in relation to some of the private risks that I've mentionedNikki Deol Chief Legal Officer - 0:36:44
that are in your exempt paper. What did happen for the organisation was that DTS, our organisation,they stepped in and they issued guidance periodically so that certain aspects of the business could
continue and that was by way of teams but in terms of the incident management I'd have
to come back to you in relation to whether that was equipped sufficiently to deal with
that sole issue.
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:37:15
Any more questions on this before we go on to close session?Councillor Jenkins.
Thank you.
Cllr David Jenkins CA Member - 0:37:21
So this is a bit about demarcation in a way with scrutiny.So some of the items, so on page 18 about the transport facilities, it mentions about
Flixbus wanting an agent in the Leeds bus station.
I just wondered what's the context of that?
and maybe some of the scrutiny has to take up.
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:37:50
Cllr David Jenkins CA Member - 0:37:52
But on the next paragraph it says, due to change in guidance.So it doesn't explain what the change in the guidance is.
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:38:02
Cllr David Jenkins CA Member - 0:38:05
Can I explain that to you in a private session because that matters subject to litigation?Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer - 0:38:08
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:38:14
Any further questions?Can we move to closed session please?
6 Risk Management
7 External Audit Update
Cllr David Jenkins CA Member - 0:38:23
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer - 0:38:44
Meg Williams Committee Services Officer - 0:38:49
Nikki Deol Chief Legal Officer - 0:38:56
Okay, agenda item 7.Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:39:08
This is the external audit update and it's to present the draught auditor's annual reportfor the year ending March 26.
Is it Kate or Alistair?
Straight to Alistair.
Alistair?
Alastair Newall (Auditor) Mazars - 0:39:21
Thank you, Chair, and thanks for the introduction.I was going to say that although it's called an update, it is actually our draught auditor's
annual report.
For members who are new to the external audit cycle, this is one of our key audit outputs.
Robbie toense we're sending a
ruthless
fac poison
when we will issue the final. Noting that it is draught, that allows me the opportunity
to correct the couple of typographical and inaccurate comments that members have alerted
me to outside of the meeting before we issue that final one.
Just to summarise for members because the majority of the information in this report
is relating to our value for money responsibility.
That responsibility, which is in the National Audit Office's Code of Audit practise, is
to consider whether the authority has proper arrangements to deliver value for money in
its use of resources.
The NAO set out the criteria that all auditors have to consider.
And as you can see in the report, they cover three criteria, arrangements for financial
sustainability, for governance, and for improving economy efficiency and effectiveness.
So the report summarises our views on the authorities' arrangements across those three
areas.
And in summary, the work is complete, but the report is still in draught because if anything
comes to light between now and us completing the audit by the end of January, then we would
go back and reconsider the outcome of that work.
The headlines for you are that we've concluded the authority does have proper arrangements
in place for the year 25 -26.
In the previous year we reported two weaknesses in those arrangements.
They are summarised and reported on page 24 and 25 of our report.
Based on the work we've completed this year, we've concluded that both weaknesses have
been addressed, leading to our view that proper arrangements are in place.
We have, you'll see, on page 14 of our report, reported an other recommendation.
So this is not an area of significant weakness, but it is an area where the authority is working,
recognises and is working on strengthening its arrangements, and those relate to the
development of a single medium -term financial strategy document, which pulls together the
strands that exist currently that the authority uses to manage that and present to members
the
audit, and we will be looking at the
audit and the financial plan.
So happy to take questions.
As I said, the audit will be completed in January, at which
point we will issue the final version of this report.
But happy chair to take any questions.
≫ Thank you, Alistair.
I'm pleased to see that the previous concerns over the controls has been addressed so thank
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:43:11
you to Kate and her team because I know you've done a lot of work on that, haven't you, toget us to that point?
So that's good.
Any questions?
Rob?
Thanks, Chair.
Rob Winter (Independent Member) - 0:43:19
I was going to comment again.It's nice to tick things off, isn't it?
Lovely to tick things off.
I know this is subject to the next report but on page 46 of the pack you are stating
that you intend to issue a disclaimer opinion, which obviously is disappointing from the
authorities point of view because we would like to get back to a full audit. I would
just like to understand, is it us or is it you? In blunt terms. Is it because it's something
that the authority hasn't been able to do or is it something within the auditing, the
remain a problem.
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:44:05
I said you want to reply, I think we have covered this point before haven't we, butI think it's probably worth reiterating.
Alastair Newall (Auditor) Mazars - 0:44:12
I think at the last meeting I hope, I know you weren't there Rob, no no so I'm happyto reiterate that and hopefully members were reassured by the discussion last time.
So a very direct question and in typical audit fashion I'm probably not going to answer it
with a direct, it's one or the other.
It is circumstance and it is the situation that we find ourselves in the combined authority
and at many, many authorities across the country where we have a historical position of disclaimer
disclaimed audit opinions being given and now needing to get a way forward to get to
issuing unqualified opinions.
That is neither quick nor straightforward.
And the journey that's led us to where we are now has been quite lengthy and detailed
involving those in the sector in senior positions across the sector, in CLG, in the National
Audit Office, alongside all the audit firms, to try and identify a way forward to move
from disclaim to unqualified.
We now have that framework in place, and at our firm we have a framework in place where
we are moving now from disclaimed to unqualified.
That's happening this year in 2526.
I'm sorry, I work in previous years, so when I say this year I mean 2526, not 2627.
In 2526 we are moving a small number, admittedly, but a small number from disclaimed to initially
qualified and then unqualified in future years.
And we are running a series of pilots for those
authorities to establish how do we do that, where are
the lessons to be learned, in order that the rest of
the audits can follow that in a very appropriate,
time -effective, time -efficient way,
acknowledging that it's going to take significant
amounts of audit time and authority time to help us
get to that position.
I'm actually quite glad we're not in a pilot.
We're not at the forefront of this at the command
authority because I think we will learn a lot of
lessons from those that are happening.
And the conversations that I've had with Kate and her
finance team are, at the moment, are around the risk
work that we're doing, the risk arrangements work,
identifying where those risks of misstatement might
be in the unaudited balances and the unaudited reserves
that mean we would need to carry out further audit procedures.
Once we've concluded that and been through the, as you can imagine,
lengthy internal moderation processes so that my risk department
are comfortable that I'm not taking a flyer on these things,
once we've got to that stage and we've got a list of audit procedures that we will need to do,
at that point the conversations turn to not what and how, but when.
And you'll then get that feedback as to what is the plan, how much can we do next year,
how much can we do the following year, what's the timeframe.
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:47:22
Rob Winter (Independent Member) - 0:47:25
Thanks, I'm very familiar with the back storey to this problem, but I suppose from our committee'spoint of view where the chair is required to sign the accounts in the absence, and we've
We've been here before, obviously.
In the absence of a full audit, I suppose from the committee's point of view, we're
placing extra reliance on Kate.
And I suppose there's the assurance when you make reference to the risk of there being
material misstatements in some of those opening balances, not necessarily for now, it can
be a later meeting is what has the finance department done to be as assured as possible
that there are no risks of misstatement so that we can place we can compensate the lack
of external audit assurance through the, you know, Kate's team.
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:48:21
Kate, do you want to come back?Kate Taylor, Director West Yorkshire Combined Authority - 0:48:27
So, I mean, I would point you back probably to the work that we did last year on lastfinancial statements because you know we almost ordered them ourselves I think
it'd be fair to say with the new team that were in place at that point in time
who came in with that fresh pair of eyes and have been able to do that and I you
know we have we put a number of misstatements forward and some of those
were very historic in terms of the treatments in there so I think that you
know should give you some assurance that we have looked significantly back in
terms of that. That team is now in place, we have moved, just kind of moved someone
that was on contract into permanent which was fantastic so we are fully
resourced in that area as well with that team that are now sort of into their
second and third years of being with the authority to starting to build that
knowledge and that confidence that is in there. What I would also say is not only
does Debbie have to sign, I have to sign a statement of responsibilities that
legally binds me as well in terms of that as you'll know yourself Rob but
other councillors I did modify that statement of responsibilities last year
to reflect that there could be some issues that would come out because of
the nature of some of the historic things that we were finding I think and
we will we will be clearing this in the report that comes through to the
January committee with the accounts around actually that the continued work
that we have done on that and where we kind of feel that we have picked up and there might
be some areas that we feel but we've kind of picked off the big stuff I think where
we feel that there is material leaving the things that we know are lower risk in terms
of that.
But I think on the whole there's always more to do and the team are brilliant in terms
of always finding more to do but I think we feel in a much more comfortable place that
we understand what we are dealing with and we know where there are things that we need
to do now rather than before where it was a bit like we actually don't know where we
need to go.
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:50:30
Rob Winter (Independent Member) - 0:50:32
Thanks Kate, again from the committee's point of view it's understanding that there's apositive direction of travel that from an authority point of view we are clearing the
uncertainties and whatever problems there might have been with balances.
So we can, I'm not putting you on the spot because it will be in the next meeting, that
we could expect to see a cleaner, if you like, view from you this year than last year.
And I suppose it would be useful in that to understand what is still an area of, I hesitate
say concern, but an area of lack of full clarification that means we're still in this sort of disclaimed
opinion. Because from my point of view, forgive the blunt question, always being assured that
the authority has done everything it possibly can to produce a clean set and robust set
of accounts. And if it is the audit mechanism that is creating the disclaimed opinion, we
need to understand that, that it's not something that the authority is holding
up, for want of a better phrase. Yeah and just to you know kind of Alice described
I think we're working really closely together so I don't think it's a you us
position. As we sit here now I am not intending to modify my state of
responsibilities on on this set of accounts coming, which you know I
probably knew at this point last year that I was going to modify my statement
of responsibilities on the previous year's accounts. So no, I would not, unless something
happens between now and January in terms of that, but no, I have much more comfort and
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:52:22
assurance within my team. I think if I recall correctly, last year Kate, you brought tothe committee some work to say what you had done in terms of making sure everything was
right and some of the risks that were still there and I think it'd be useful to have something
similar this year. I think we can do certainly a reflection back on that. I think we bought
Kate Taylor, Director West Yorkshire Combined Authority - 0:52:46
two papers last year which was one which was around the accounts because there were somesignificant material changes that we had made and there was one around the recovery plan
which was to effect execute so I think we can wrap that up into one. Nice, six in. That
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:52:57
would be useful and that will also help give me assurance to be able to sign everythingoff so yeah that'd be good thank you. Any other questions on the paper? No okay so
could please record that that's been noted and we'll move on to our final
agenda item which is quarter 2 Treasury Management update and I think Kate
that's back to you again please. It is thank you Chair. So this is the quarter
two report at the last meeting you had the quarter one report so as follows
you will get one every quarter for that. There is I guess nothing of significance for me
Kate Taylor, Director West Yorkshire Combined Authority - 0:53:41
to draw to your attention around this report for that. So we are within our prudentialindicators so I have no kind of no issues to report to you there. Our position you know
continues to be from an authority perspective one of investing rather than being a borrowing
authority and you'll see we've taken out no kind of additional borrowing and that was
in line with what we expected in our treasury management strategy for this year. In terms
of that, so yeah, steady as you go, what you will see actually is the performance of the
treasury management income is performing better than we expected through budget. There's two
reasons for that, well one reason ultimately, which is higher cash balances but driven by
two factors. One is we received some additional monies from the government post -budget setting
in there, so some new funds were announced which have come in and we're now holding for those,
and in some areas some of the programmes have been slower to get off the ground than we had originally
seen, so therefore we are holding those cash balances longer. That is good news for us as
authority because we should be aware we are doing bus franchising and you'll see
on the risk register quite a lot of the risks we hold around the bus network
currently until we are fully in that franchise piece so that gives us our
resilience that we need to be able to support the transport network through
that period in there so no nothing further to add on the Treasury
management in itself for that. Other than just to note to you this is a little bit weird,
in the February meeting we will be bringing the draught treasury management strategy for
27 28 for you to review and provide that scrutiny function before it goes to the combined authority
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:55:39
in March for final sign off. Thanks Kate. Questions? Rob?Rob Winter (Independent Member) - 0:55:43
Thanks, Debbie.On page 70, there's a number of lines that don't have an interest rate.
Are we lending it for free?
I assume we're not.
Sorry, page 78.
There's a number of lines where there's no interest rate which I assume we're not giving
it for free but why that would be the case.
Rob Winter (Independent Member) - 0:56:26
Whether I mean it's constituent authority so I didn't know whether it was mates rates.I didn't think it would be but.
So no, those are actually, bizarrely, those are some historic arrangements that have been
Kate Taylor, Director West Yorkshire Combined Authority - 0:56:43
in place for a number of years.I will dig out the specific detail of those.
So it was money that was given and I think it was at the time under an interest free
arrangement, I think linked to the evolution deal at the time and supporting particular
projects.
All of those are due to be repaid this year in terms of there.
So perhaps take that as a naivety of an authority at the very beginning of its journey.
In terms of that in those arrangements, but yes, all of those are due back in this year.
And as you can see, the rest have all got interest rates in there.
So it is very much a historic arrangement in place for those.
I would say not all of those are districts as well.
there is one from Barnsley in there for example in there so they're in the
Yorkshire region but they relate to specific projects that were regional
regional projects within Yorkshire at the time so they were specific reasons
Rob Winter (Independent Member) - 0:57:46
to help support those getting on. Perhaps a footnote if given that this is in thepublic domain it could be misinterpreted as if it's mates rates given the
councils that are listed there. Any other questions on the paper?
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:58:05
Cllr Alex Greenwood CA Member - 0:58:09
Councillor Greenwood then Councillor Cuming. Yes, I notice the MUFG forecast is from Septemberand it's already gone up to 4%. So is the authority still working on the assumption
that they will fall over the next year or two and has any kind of sensitivity training
being done around it at all?
Kate Taylor, Director West Yorkshire Combined Authority - 0:58:34
So we do do sensitivity training. The main thing that actually, the interest rates themselves,so yeah, Leeds will look at that when they do the work with us and look at what is the
right rate to use. The biggest thing that actually impacts us in terms of how much investment
income is actually the cash balances, so that is the big driver, more so probably than the
interest rates at the moment because that is the bigger number and that is the more
variable number that sits within there. It is really challenging at the moment and if
you know kind of any of the Treasury management kind of teams as they say, the last two years
have been incredibly difficult for them to forecast in terms of that. At the moment because
we are not actively borrowing, we are not particularly exposed in that sense. So if
we were borrowing or if I had to go out and borrow now and I absolutely had a need to
borrow, I would be borrowing at higher rates than if I can push that out for example. Hopefully
in a couple of years where the forecasts are showing but as we know those forecasts do
keep moving. So it is really tricky at the moment to do those but we are quite fortunate
I think we are not in a position where we have to be exposed yet.
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 0:59:45
Thank you.Councillor CUMMING.
It is the banks section.
At the end you have the fixed term deposits, long term.
You have three types of banks.
Cllr Cllr Simon Brophy Kirklees Council - 0:59:58
Why is there such a discrepancy in interest rates?Because you have a start and end date and multiple of these.
Cllr Robin Cumming CA Member - 1:00:05
and you know you're looking at 28 million you know which is one of the largest figuresat a really low percentage.
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 1:00:12
Cllr Robin Cumming CA Member - 1:00:14
Page 80.No 82.
Kate Taylor, Director West Yorkshire Combined Authority - 1:00:25
So those are those are related to ultimately those are our kind of say call accounts sothose are where our excess cash is so think like sweep accounts so they don't necessarily
get very high rates because they're kind of going on overnight effectively and
where we hold excess cash and ready cash in there. So they don't particularly hold
really high levels. What we will do is where we don't need cash for a
particular period of time, so we'll obviously be cash forecasting every week
of what we need to be able to pay bills, what we need to pay drawdowns for
example on schemes, we keep a certain amount of ready cash. Where we don't we'll
it into short term deposits and long term deposits because we can get better rates through
that as you can see the rates are much better for us.
Q. Is this confusing to fixed term? It tends to be like cash. Have you seen cash? It's
there, it's not like a term. It's already accessible.
Kate Taylor, Director West Yorkshire Combined Authority - 1:01:18
A. Yes, yes. So call would be on cash.Q. So it's just a fixed term. It confuses me. It looks like it's running it for a certain
period of time.
Yes, so with that we would put a deposit on for a certain period of time.
It's effectively, if you think of like putting something into an ISA that you can't withdraw
then for a certain number of periods.
So if you think of like some savings accounts, you put it in, you can't then get that money
out, we will put it on, we will guarantee it for six months to go into that account
and that guarantees a certain rate.
Generally the longer you can put them on, sometimes the better rates that you get in
terms of there so the longer that you could invest your money out and deposit
it out there the better the rate that you will get.
No, so that's all set out in the Treasury Management Strategy around what we will do.
Again, it depends on how I will need the cash and we'd like to keep it generally a bit of
a mix in terms of what we can do.
In terms of that, because of the nature of some of our programmes being a bit longer, actually
I can send money out a little bit quicker in terms of being able to do that.
A council's financial position is significantly different because you're collecting tax on
very regular basis so the cash flow is far more dynamic in that sense so and
you know a council will often be short -term borrowing for operational
expenditure that we don't do so I have the ability to be able to put money out
ultimately mix a mix of money to be able to spread our risk but also then to be
able to maximise the best interest rates that that I can ultimately for this
authority because every pound that I can make means that we have more money to support initiatives
and the resilience of this organisation.
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 1:03:30
Rob Winter (Independent Member) - 1:03:35
Thanks Debbie. For my understanding, obviously this is a snapshot at the end of a quarter.If we looked at it today it could be a significantly different number because of that cash flow.
I suppose the principle of, without looking back at previous quarterly Treasury management
reports, is that £58 million a typical figure and how has that been judged to be the right
match?
That sounds a lot of money when you haven't got the same, you know, you haven't got a
£20 million monthly payroll going out or anything like that.
I know you're paying lots of creditors but I suppose it's the basis upon which that level
of cash is held that the opportunity cost of that is obviously investing and getting
some interest.
So you're absolutely right that I don't necessarily have a large wage bill in the sense of that
Kate Taylor, Director West Yorkshire Combined Authority - 1:04:29
but things like rail stations for example and bus depots do not come cheaply in termsof that so you know kind of as say my cash profile will move from week to week it is
very rarely under 10 million pound a week that I'm not drawing down and it has been
in the tens of millions for quite a number of weeks because of the number of transactions
that have been going through. And if you look at kind of the profile of our capital programme,
that was always back -ended. So naturally we were having, as work is accelerating through
and the programmes are stepping up, we are having to draw that down in terms of that.
But ultimately it's between us as a, you know, us providing our cash flow and then that conversation
with Leeds who manage our treasury management service for us that will then decide they
will use their TMS expertise of what is the best level to keep.
Debbie Simpson, Chair (Independent Member) - 1:05:24
Thank you. Any other questions? No? Okay. So if you can record, the paper has been noted.And that brings us to the end of the meeting, so thank you everyone for your participation.
8 Q2 Treasury Management Update
10 Date of Next Meeting
The next meeting of the committee will take place at 10 o 'clock on the 29th of January.
Thank you.
- 5. 261008 G&A Minutes - 8 Oct 2026 DRAFT, opens in new tab
- Item 6 - Risk Management, opens in new tab
- Item 6 - Appendix 1 - Corporate ROAP (Risk on a Page), opens in new tab
- Item 6 - Appendix 3 - Guidance Information for Committee Members, opens in new tab
- Item 7 - External Audit Update, opens in new tab
- Item 7 - Appendix 1 – WYCA Auditor's Annual Report 2025-26 Final Draft, opens in new tab
- Item 8 - Q2 Treasury Management Update, opens in new tab
- Item 8 - Appendix 1 – Investment Counterparty List 30 September 2026, opens in new tab